A heated rift has erupted in the OnlyFans creator community, with popular model Sophie Rain publicly slamming controversial content creator Bonnie Blue for what she describes as turning the platform into a “clown show” and jeopardizing its credibility for serious performers.

In a pointed statement to The Blast, Sophie Rain expressed frustration over Blue’s headline-grabbing antics, including fake weddings, mock arrests, and extreme sexual stunts, accusing her of undermining the hard-fought legitimacy many creators have built.

“It’s no longer women empowerment,” Sophie Rain said. “It’s shock value, and she’s making a joke out of all of us. We built this space to take control of our bodies and make money on our terms—not to fake pregnancies, marriages, and throw cake at people in public.”

Bonnie Blue has been permanently banned from OnlyFans following what the company described as violations of its Acceptable Use Policy related to “extreme challenge content.”

The 25-year-old from Derbyshire previously claimed to have made up to $800,000 a month, but her increasingly sensational content, including a proposed event dubbed “Bonnie Blue’s Petting Zoo,” where she would be tied naked in a glass box for public interaction, triggered widespread outrage.

“She’s crossed a line,” a source said. “OnlyFans had no choice but to act.”

Other stunts included a faked arrest and repeated attempts to sneak into football matches in disguise, culminating in a lifetime stadium ban from Nottingham Forest.

Sophie Rain: “We’re Not All Doing Circus Acts for Clicks”

Rain emphasized that Blue’s behavior not only reflects poorly on her but also damages the entire ecosystem for creators who rely on the platform as a legitimate source of income.

“Brands don’t take us seriously anymore. Media doesn’t take us seriously,” Sophie Rain said. “I’m tired of having to explain that not all of us are doing circus acts for clicks. I’d really like to know who’s running her clown show.”

OnlyFans, which became a lifeline for many during the pandemic, has long straddled the line between empowerment and controversy. Rain’s comments underscore the growing tension between creators seeking professional respect and those chasing viral fame at any cost.

Bonnie Blue first gained notoriety with claims of sleeping with over 1,000 men in 12 hours and has continued to push boundaries with provocative public stunts. Her recent content, however, drew the line for regulators and even fans, with many accusing her of promoting harmful narratives around consent and sexual violence.

Sophie Rain, too, has faced criticism, most recently for speaking openly about her Christian faith while working in adult content. She responded to critics in a separate statement:

“People love to weaponize religion when it’s convenient for them,” she said. “If God gave me this platform, this body, and this voice, why wouldn’t I use it?… The same men calling me a disgrace are the ones who subscribed to my page. If you think I’m so sinful, maybe cancel your subscription first.”

As the OnlyFans platform continues to evolve, Rain’s remarks spotlight the internal clash over identity, values, and professional legitimacy—and the high-stakes consequences of content that pushes past what even adult platforms are willing to host.

• Follow Sophie Rain on X at @sophieraiin.
• Follow Bonnie Blue on X at @bonnieblue_xoxo.