“This Ain’t Gilligan’s Island XXX”: A Porn Parody Too Far?

After AEE, we'd pretty much come to terms with the fact that "Not The" and "This Ain't" style porn parodies were here to stay—and we'd even come to appreciate, and actually like, the genre.

That, however, was before we saw the trailer for "This Ain't Gilligan's Island XXX.

A well-done porn parody comes across as a loving, cross-genre tribute to mainstream entertainment—like when Cat Power covers "Satisfaction." What makes Will Ryder great is that his movies actually seem like remakes of the original show—just with a bunch of sex thrown in.

"This Ain't Gilligan's Island XXX," however, looks like a throwback to an earlier era of porn parody: the intro song sucks, with only a bare minimum of resemblance to the original, and the "plot" doesn't seem very "Gilligan's Island"-esque (a porn within a porn? Are you serious?). And we gotta say, we don't think Gilligan would be throwing around the word "whore" like that.

We never thought we'd hear ourselves say this, but "Gilligan's Island" deserves better.

· This Ain't Gilligan's Island XXX (hustlerworld.com)