Quite frankly, we don't see why the anonymous author(s) of this website are so freaked out by whether superstar amateur model Kate of Kate's Playground has a deformed foot or not; we think she's perfect enough otherwise that it doesn't matter much what may be happening below her right ankle. Besides—the fetish net being as wide as it is, we're sure it's even bringing her some new fans.

"The Mystery of Kate's Hoof Toe" (staticnine.com - thanks Chris*)
Kate's Playground: "Canada's Hottest Teen" (preview galleries @ katesplayground.com)

*Update The original page linked above has been taken down, but you can examine the evidence at (where else) HoofGirl.com (thanks Rick)